SporeView gets an honorable mention!

Maxis sent me an email tonight letting me know that my Spore API contest entry, SporeView, has won an honorable mention. I’m actually really relieved to have gotten some recognition because
- I lost a lot of sleep making SporeView
- The winning entries were, how do you say, lame
OK, they weren’t that bad. The Augmented reality app that won the competition is actually very cool despite being a little unpolished. It builds wireframe skeletons from the vector data available in the creature xml which is no doubt impressive. If the mesh data for the creature parts themselves were made available through a service then PaperVision 3D could have actually been used to build an accurate model of a creature. I looked into this when thinking up ideas but realized mesh data wasn’t available moved on (thinking that wireframe skeletons were just too plain to do Spore creatures any justice). I hate to say it but the augmented reality portion of this app is, well, a gimmick. AR is cool, but its being done to death right now. As a developer I see trends come and go so I just have to laugh a little at the AR craze. I hate to think that the AR portion of this really pushed it over the top since the wireframe rendering is the big accomplishment here. Regardless, big up to to Aaron Meyers and his Spore Skeltons app.
The second and third place winners were a non-asynchronous Javascript and Flash creature browser (I thought asynchronous web apps was just expected nowadays) and a .NET based desktop app that isn’t cross-platform and doesn’t warrant a desktop-app (plus building non cross-platform apps from web-services defeats the purpose of a service based API in my opinion). Not what I would expect out of a silver and a bronze.
I know I sound like a sore loser here. I really am happy to have gotten an honorable mention. I just build apps day in and day out so I have a lot of strong opinions about what makes an application actually good (being in Flex is always a good start!). In any event, much thanks to Maxis for putting on the competition and we’ll see if I can’t find the time to continue to add new features to SporeView.




